Subscription and demo access


 
About Interfax
Press Releases
Products & Services
Contact us
Customer Login
 


Headlines
 

08/14 22:01   Number of truce breaches in Idlib rises - Russian military
 
08/14 22:01   Five militant drones destroyed near Hmeimim airbase last evening, 16 since early Aug - Russian Defense Ministry
 
08/14 21:28   Ukrainian troops attack school, house in Horlivka - Donetsk People's Republic
 
08/14 21:11   Two Russians held at Kyiv detention facility ask to be swapped for Ukrainian prisoner in Russia - ombudsman
 
08/14 20:45   Bogdanov, Lebanese delegation discuss return of Syrian refugees to homeland
 
08/14 20:34   Georgian shepherd accused of murdering U.S. family fit to stand trial
 
08/14 20:23   Kadyrov sees no chance of improving relations with U.S., sanctions relief in near future
 
08/14 20:17   Caspian Sea Convention to enable Azerbaijan to lay pipelines along sea bottom - Foreign Ministry
 
08/14 20:03   Justice for Journalists promises help in identifying those responsible for crimes against media workers
 
08/14 20:00   Ruble extends gains as int'l capital markets stabilize
 


 

Interfax.com  |  Interfax news  |  Reforms in Ukraine result in coexistence of 2...


News headlines


February 05, 2018 21:31

Reforms in Ukraine result in coexistence of 2 supreme courts

KYIV. Feb 5 (Interfax) - A peculiar 'judicial diarchy' has emerged in Ukraine, a conflict of laws in which two supreme courts have been simultaneously existing in the country for about two months, as the new Supreme Court had been created during the judicial reform, while the old one was not abolished.

"We have not received an executive order, on the basis of which one could say that the Supreme Court was abolished. [...] We must sit down and think how to exit this deadlock," Vasyl Humeniuk, the acting chair of the 'old' Ukrainian Supreme Court, said at a briefing in Kyiv on Monday.

It is necessary to legally entrench the handover of the legacy of the Ukrainian Supreme Court to the newly created Supreme Court, he said. "These issues have been discussed, communication with the authorities [the president, the Verkhovna Rada] is underway in order to fight the legal solution to this situation," Humeniuk said.

The 'old' Ukrainian Supreme Court has requested the Constitutional Court to provide a legal definition of the cessation of its work during the launch of the 'new' Supreme Court, in particular, in terms of reviewing the possibility of abolishing the Ukrainian Supreme Court as a constitutional body without introducing amendments to the Constitution, he said. But the Ukrainian Constitutional Court rendered no decision, Humeniuk said.

The similar situation had happened in Croatia during the reorganization, but the country's Constitutional Court resolved the issue, Humeniuk said, when asked whether two supreme courts have ever existed simultaneously in the world history.

As reported, on October 3, 2017, the Ukrainian Verkhovna Rada adopted a bill introducing amendments to a number of the country's legal acts ensuring the conclusion of the judicial reform. One of the innovations of the bill is defining the Supreme Court as the single cassation instance and introducing the new procedure of hearing cases in it.

On November 22, 2017, Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko signed the bill. Prior to that, in early November, Poroshenko signed a decree appointing 114 judges of the new Supreme Court.

The new Supreme Court began its operations on December 15, 2017, it is now the main and only cassation instance, while the old one had ceased operations.

Thus, the old Supreme Court continues working without administering justice, as it is done by the new one, and expects the president and the parliament to decide on its abolition, Humeniuk said.

According to the Constitution, a court may be abolition or reorganized on the basis of the president's decree approved by the Supreme Judicial Council and the Verkhovna Rada, he said. In addition, the constitutional principle of the distribution of power should be taken into consideration, it prevents one branch of the government from destroying another one via an order or decree, he said.

When asked how exactly the Ukrainian Supreme Court could be abolished, Humeniuk said: "I don't know how it should be resolved, but [we] have clearly raised the question in our constitutional request, we see that it cannot be abolished in this case, there should be some other form."

The abolition envisages an institution losing its functions, the destruction of its documents, archives, resolving an issue of ownership of its premises.

"The thing that is scary about the abolition is that it has consequences. [...] The Ukrainian Supreme Court's hard disc and other classified materials are being destroyed during the abolition, we cannot hand over documents to a court for further use," Humeniuk said.

For instance, the abolition means destroying the case on rehabilitation of victims of political repressions in Ukraine which had been head in 1991-1998, he said. "It's about the fates of people. I won't resort to that [the abolition]!" he said.

A total of 13 judges are currently working at the old Supreme Court, he said.

"The judges go to work, study the new legislation. We also work as a post box, people send requests to us regarding rehabilitation cases among other things. We are incapable of hearing cases, but we perform our functions," he said.

The judges of the Supreme Court are currently being paid 'a bare salary' and 'waiting for their fate," he said.

The judges were elected for an indefinite term, Humeniuk said. He said he is unaware whether the judges requested to be transferred to other courts.

Mg iz

(Our editorial staff can be reached at eng.editors@interfax.ru)

/Interfax/
 Subscription
You can access a demo version of, receive more information about or subscribe to Interfax publications by filling in and returning the form below. We also have dozens of reports in the Russian language, please indicate if you are interested.
Title:


Phone:


E-mail:


First name:


Company:


Country:
Last name:


Division:


City:
Products:
Central Asia & Caucasus Business Weekly
Central Asia General Newswire
Global Gas Analytics
Global Natural Gas Daily
Interfax Via Bloomberg Terminal
Kazakhstan General Newswire
Kazakhstan Mining Weekly
Kazakhstan Oil & Gas Weekly
Russia & CIS Announcements
Russia & CIS Banking and Finance Weekly
Russia & CIS Business and Financial Daily
Russia & CIS Business and Financial Newswire
Russia & CIS Business and Investment Weekly
Russia & CIS Business Law Weekly
Russia & CIS Business news
Russia & CIS Defense Industry Weekly
Russia & CIS Diplomatic Panorama
Russia & CIS Energy Daily
Russia & CIS Energy Newswire
Russia & CIS Events Calendar
Russia & CIS Food and Agriculture Weekly
Russia & CIS General Newswire
Russia & CIS Headline News
Russia & CIS Insurance Weekly
Russia & CIS IT and Telecom Weekly
Russia & CIS Metals and Mining Weekly
Russia & CIS Military Daily
Russia & CIS Military Newswire
Russia & CIS Military Weekly
Russia & CIS Oil and Gas Weekly
Russia & CIS Presidential Bulletin
Russia & CIS Statistics Weekly
Russia Health & Pharmaceuticals
Russia Market Roundup
Russia Press Review
Ukraine Business Daily
Ukraine Business Weekly
Ukraine General Newswire
Please enter the digits from picture in the box below:

August 14, 2018
 
22:01
Number of truce breaches in Idlib rises - Russian military
 
22:01
Five militant drones destroyed near Hmeimim airbase last evening, 16 since early Aug - Russian Defense Ministry
 
21:28
Ukrainian troops attack school, house in Horlivka - Donetsk People's Republic
 
21:11
Two Russians held at Kyiv detention facility ask to be swapped for Ukrainian prisoner in Russia - ombudsman
 
20:45
Bogdanov, Lebanese delegation discuss return of Syrian refugees to homeland
 
20:34
Georgian shepherd accused of murdering U.S. family fit to stand trial
 
20:23
Kadyrov sees no chance of improving relations with U.S., sanctions relief in near future
 
20:17
 
20:03
Justice for Journalists promises help in identifying those responsible for crimes against media workers
 
20:00
Ruble extends gains as int'l capital markets stabilize
 
19:59
Canadian company to deliver LRT-3 sniper rifles to Ukraine
 
19:56
Psycholinguistic analysis of Jewish movement leader's social media posts to take a month
 
19:54
Orenburg mayor held on bribery suspicion
 
19:50
High-level group to meet in Baku in autumn to look into implementation of convention on legal status of Caspian Sea - Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry
 
 more headlines 



Interviews
 

.
NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg has given an interview to Interfax ahead of the alliances summit in Brussels on July 11-12, in which he about Russias place on the summits agenda and how NATO is going to build relations with Russia.

more
.
.
U.S. National Security Advisor John Bolton visited Moscow on June 27 to lay the groundwork for the first full-fledged meeting between Russian President Vladimir Putin and U.S. President Donald Trump.

more
.
.
UK Ambassador to Russia Laurie Bristow has given an interview to Interfax in which he speaks about the level of cooperation with Russia as part of preparations for the FIFA World Cup, his expectation as to the number of British fans who will come to Russia and other aspects of preparing for the tournament.

more

 
  
 ©   1991—2018   Interfax Information Service. All rights reserved.
contact information   |   Interfax offices   |   made by web.finmarket

News and other data on this site are provided for information purposes only, and are not intended for republication or redistribution. Republication or redistribution of Interfax content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Interfax.

Browse other Interfax sites:  Interfax.ru   |   IFX.RU   |   Interfax Group   Rambler's Top100